» » Small Talk « «



About me
A bachelor living in Delhi, a city he loves and loathes, documents his experiences on this page. He is erratic, opinionated and lazy, loves his women, wine and song - what more do you need to know?
   

<< January 2004 >>
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
 01 02 03
04 05 06 07 08 09 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30 31

My old blog

My A List    >>

Ajay    •    Alka    •    Andrea    •    Anita    •    Aqua    •    Avlokana    •    BaghdadBurning    •    Beautiful Life    •    C'est la vie    •   Charu    •    Dave Barry   •    Deepan    •    Delhi Brat    •    Dina    •    Divya    •  Evan    •    Gigaom    •    Gorgeous    •    Jill    •   Jivha •    Jo    •    Journeywoman   •   Kash    •   Khotta       •    Khushee    •   Lazy Lump   •    Leviathan   •    Lost Highway   •    MadMax   •    Meenaa    •    Megan    •    Nancy Gandhi    •   Nandini    •    Neha    •    NonSensei    •   Pallavi   •    Patrix    •    Pompy    •    Priya   •    Rebecca   •    Ritika    •    Ritu    •    Sakhi    •    Salam Pax    •   Sandhya    •    Sanjay    •    Selective Amnesia   •   SSimon    •    Snapdragon   •    Swne   •    T-Fairy   •   Varnam    •    Venkat    •    Wandy   •   Wonder Bug



My Daily Dose    >>

Dilbert
Equitymaster
Friends
IITIIM
Living in India
Mensa
Moneycontrol
Seinfeld

If you want to be updated on this weblog Enter your email here:



rss feed



Wednesday, January 21
Another rerun! Where do all Muslims go??

Its the season for repeats!! This one becomes relevant as elections loom around the corner...

Today let me touch upon a topic very close to my heart....the issue of integration of Muslims in India.

Ever since I was growing up in a small town in India, we have had Muslim friends and neighbours, and I have some warm memories of that time. The succulent mutton that used to come from Salim's house during Id, the great joy one used to feel when his Boodhi Nani (grandma) used to come down...the smell of onion always emanating from their kitchen....

Strangely though, I hardly got to study with any Muslim classmates. In school, engineering college or even at my IIM, Muslims made for just about 1% of the class. This is odd because India is supposed to have over 20% people of this community. If you look around, in the army, the police, and the corporate world or in the academia, the representation from Muslims is hardly noticeable. I don’t think its because of any discrimination....the most probable reason is that most Muslims (except the high or middle class urbanites) finish their schooling in some madrassa, which while providing them with good practical or spiritual knwoledge, make them unfit to join the mainstream.

Does India hate Muslims? Unlikely. Most of our highly respected musicians (Bismillah Khan, Bharat Ratna, Vilayat Khan, Amjad Ali Khan, Fahimuddin Dagar, Zakir Hussain et al), movie stars (Amir Khan, Shahrukh Khan, Tabu) and many beloved sportsmen (Azhar, Zahir, Kaif, Aslam Sher Khan, Nawab Pataudi, Md. Shahid) belong to this community......and more Hindus than Muslims stood against the carnage in Gujarat, which incidentally was a one-off tragedy in the history of India.

The only beneficiaries of the backwardness of Muslims are the Mullahs, Imams and sundry politicians who then can herd the faithful to their own ends. Sadly, the Islamic intellectuals who want to reform their community are beaten down by their own brethren who call them anti-Muslims. Rafiq Zakaria, Mushirul Hassan and Maulana Wali Mohammed come to mind. Some of the greatest minds in the world are Muslims, and most of them are tolerant, cultured and secular. Most Muslims do not marry four times, and in today's world, most of them do not just say talaq talaq talaq before throwing their wives out. They do not cheer for Pakistan in a match with India, and definitely do not nurse an ambition to go to Lahore some day. These are stereotypes created by the black sheep from the other religions, of course with help from their ilk from the folds of Islam.

No amount of political bickering will ever change the fate of Muslims in India. Their young men will have to take charge of their futures. They will need to get the very best of education, then compete for the very best of positions and then assert their voice in every domain they enter. They will need to educate their womenfolk and not restrict their passage through life. There is no dearth of talent within them....all they need to do is shed their inferiority complex.....I would love to see many more Salims (as well as beautiful Salmas!!) walking shoulder to shoulder with me!

From my old blog.

Posted at 1/21/2004 12:49:25 pm by Ranjan

mishel
August 25, 2005   07:12 PM PDT
 
good page http://www.g888.com
Queer
March 19, 2004   02:30 AM PST
 
I am not so sure though, I am not biased, but the ones that I saw do belong to the stereotypes. although i try not to generalize, it is a little hard in this case.:)
anonymous
January 23, 2004   11:34 AM PST
 
exactly my thoughts...I have had several Muslim friends myself, and I would like to see a lot more Muslims incorporating themselves into the mainstream rather than remaining at the fringes of 'modern' India....And it is definitely true that the Hindu-Muslim divide is more of a baseless stereotype than the reality
Kash
January 21, 2004   02:03 PM PST
 
Its so tough to leave a sensible comment when sw ne has flown past (though i agree on one thing is that they are damn good looking, all muslims in my school were good looking) but still i will make an attempt. I have always wondered why they don't study and even if they study school, very few actually go on to higher education. I refuse to believe that they don't realize the importance of education
swne
January 21, 2004   01:15 PM PST
 
when u find ur salma ..find me a salim will ya ..... err..minus the beard :P ..they're darn good looking ppl. ..well that is me ...as shallow as i can be ..hehehe
 

Leave a Comment:

Name


Homepage (optional)


Comments




Previous Entry Home Next Entry